Donation Appointments Are Open!

Please review our accepted items and select a time below form your appointment. Thank you!


Woah, there! We’re so grateful that you’re thinking of donating to Pegasus, where our mission is to make arts & Crafts accessible, affordable, divert them from the landfill and put them into the wonderful, creative hands of folks in our community.

Wondering what you can donate? Check out the (super duper) comprehensive (though not exhaustive!) list below!

Art Supplies

  • Canvases

  • Paints of all Kinds

  • Print Making Supplies

  • Pastels, Charcoals, and Drawing Pencils

  • Easels

  • Stained Glass and Mosaic Materials

  • Frames

  • Sketchbooks

Scrapbook and Paper Craft

  • Quilling Supplies

  • Postcards

  • Specialty Papers

  • Paper Trimmers

  • Cutting Machines

Fabric and Notions

  • Quilting Cotton

  • Yardage

  • Leather

  • Sewing Machines

  • Quilting Rulers and Templates

  • Thread of All Kinds

  • Batting

  • Mannequins & Sewing Forms

Vintage and Collectibles

  • Photos and Slides

  • Magazines (pre-1970s)

  • Maps

  • Unique Vintage and Antique Items

  • Kitsch

Craft and Education

  • Small Toys (<4” - plastic, wood, or metal)

  • Puzzles and Games

  • Glue Guns

  • All Types of Glue

  • Beads and Jewelry Making Supplies

  • Organizing Containers

Fiber Arts

  • Yarn and Wool Roving

  • Embroidery Floss and Hoops

  • Needlework Kits

  • Your Grandma’s Linens

  • Punch Needle Supplies

Miscellaneous

  • Drawer and Cabinet Pulls

  • Hand Tools and Power Tools

  • Air bags (for packing)

  • Alcohol bottles

  • Appliances and large furniture

  • Carpet

  • Ceiling fans

  • Clothing and parts of clothing (includes socks and denim cutoffs)

  • Cloth masks

  • Computers, monitors, printers or other large electronics

  • Curtains, valances and curtain rods

  • Coffee cups, dished, pots and pans, utensils (except vintage)

  • Dried out paint

  • DVDs and VHS tapes and cases

  • Empty spray paint cans

  • Encyclopedias (unless vintage and illustration-driven)

  • Fabric scraps

  • Food jars (except mason jar, Oui yogurt jars with labels removed)

  • General household recycling (plastic food containers, aluminum cans, toilet paper rolls, egg cartons, etc.)

Items We Cannot Accept:

Pegasus Creative Reuse cannot not accept anything that has been exposed to any amount of mold, mildew, pests, hazardous chemicals, poisons, and possible allergens such as peanuts or peanut products. We will also not accept items that have been out in the rain or other elements, items that have a strong odor, or items that have been recalled by their manufacturer.

All donated items should be clean and in good reusable condition and should not pose a danger to our staff and volunteers.

Here are some commonly asked about items that we CANNOT accept.

  • Hanging file folders

  • Lamps (except vintage), cloth lamp shades or all light fixtures

  • Liquids without their original labels

  • Mattresses, bedding and towels

  • Phones (except vintage)

  • Plush toys (except Beanie Babies and other collectibles)

  • Potpourri

  • Prescription or other medication bottles

  • Shoes and cardboard shoe boxes

  • Single use plastic bags

  • Styrofoam (except craft or floral)

  • Take-out containers, utensils & straws

  • Toxic substances (or anything that contained toxic substances)

  • Weapons

  • Window blinds

“How do I donate?”

- Please be kind to our staff and volunteers, and only donate materials in a condition you'd want to receive them - organized, clean, and preferably in containers you don't need back. So much of our limited time goes into processing incoming donations. Your help with this is much appreciated.

- To ensure our tiny team is ready to greet you, donations are accepted by appointment only. Spots are limited so that we have time and space to process donations.

Please fill out the Calendly form to schedule a drop off time

- We reserve the right to refuse items even if they have been approved by form, phone, or email. We cannot accept dirty, moldy, or hazardous materials.